Introduction
Middletown, New Jersey, often celebrated for its scenic shores and charming coastal atmosphere, holds a delightful secret for those willing to venture beyond the beach: a surprisingly vibrant and diverse food scene. This gem of Monmouth County offers a culinary landscape that extends far beyond the typical Jersey shore fare. Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor seeking a delicious escape, Middletown’s eateries promise a delightful experience. This article acts as your personal guide to navigate the flavorful journey through Middletown, from cozy casual spots perfect for a family outing to upscale dining experiences ideal for marking special occasions. Get ready to discover the best “food in Middletown NJ.”
Casual Dining and Family Favorites in Middletown
When it comes to laid-back lunches, casual dinners, or finding a place that caters perfectly to the entire family, Middletown doesn’t disappoint. These establishments offer a comfortable atmosphere and delicious, approachable menus that make them community staples.
Tommy’s Coal Fired Pizza
Let’s begin with Tommy’s Coal Fired Pizza, a local favorite known for its perfectly charred crusts and fresh ingredients. Located on Highway 35, Tommy’s offers a wide array of pizzas, from classic margherita to innovative creations topped with locally sourced vegetables and artisanal cheeses. The lively atmosphere and reasonable prices make it an ideal spot for a family dinner or a casual get-together with friends. Beyond pizza, they have great sandwiches and salads, covering all the bases for everyone involved. If you’re looking for comforting, familiar, and delicious “food in Middletown NJ,” Tommy’s is a great place to start.
The Broadway Diner
Next up is The Broadway Diner, a quintessential New Jersey diner experience complete with chrome accents, plush booths, and a menu that seemingly goes on forever. Open early and staying open late, The Broadway Diner serves up classic American comfort food with generous portions. From fluffy pancakes and crispy bacon for breakfast to juicy burgers and towering sandwiches for lunch and dinner, there’s something for everyone. This place is perfect when you and the family can’t make up your minds on one particular kind of food. It also features a wide array of baked goods, from cheesecake to pie, that can cap off any great meal. It’s a reliable and beloved establishment that truly captures the spirit of casual “food in Middletown NJ.”
Delicious Orchards
And for something quick to go, Delicious Orchards is more than just your average garden center. It is famous for their apple cider donuts and pies. But it also has a sandwich shop for quick bites and eats, that are made on the spot. This can be a great place to grab some food, before exploring all of the different plants and flowers they have for sale.
Upscale Dining and Special Occasions
For those moments that call for a touch of elegance, a romantic ambiance, or a memorable culinary experience, Middletown boasts several restaurants that elevate the dining experience. These establishments focus on refined service, carefully curated menus, and an atmosphere that enhances any special occasion.
Bistro Mas
Bistro Mas is a local hot spot known for special occasions. This restaurant has live jazz music on certain nights, and has a prix fixe menu. The food is incredible, and the service is top notch.
Nicholas Creamery
Let’s turn to Nicholas Creamery. They started off as a small place offering ice cream, but have expanded to include a larger menu. They even acquired and renovated a large victorian house in the area to further expand the dining room area. Perfect for a hot summer night!
International Flavors of Middletown
Middletown’s culinary scene is a testament to its diverse community, offering a wide range of international flavors that transport you to different corners of the globe. From the vibrant spices of Mexico to the delicate artistry of Japan, these restaurants offer an authentic and enriching dining experience.
Taco Mania
First stop, Mexico, at Taco Mania. While there are many taco places throughout the state, Taco Mania does it the best. It is a great place for a quick bite, that leaves you wanting more. They have many different meats for your taco, and even have plant based options available. No matter what you get, you won’t be disappointed.
Kiku Sushi
From one delicious place to another, lets take a trip overseas to Japan with Kiku Sushi. The restaurant offers both sushi and traditional Japanese meals. Kiku only uses the freshest fish, and all of the employees are master sushi makers.
Reds
For something a little more western, we have Reds. This restaurant offers incredible italian dishes, and is even BYOB! So bring your favorite wine and enjoy their incredible food!
Hidden Gems and Local Favorites
Beyond the well-established restaurants, Middletown is also home to a number of hidden gems and local favorites that offer unique culinary experiences. These smaller establishments often boast a strong sense of community, family-run traditions, and a passion for serving delicious, homemade “food in Middletown NJ.”
Cups and Cakes
First, let’s dive into Cups and Cakes. This establishment features a range of small snacks like cupcakes, and a large range of coffee options. It is the perfect place to meet a friend and relax for the afternoon.
Local Smoke BBQ
Let’s not forget Local Smoke BBQ. They are famous for their brisket and smoked ribs, with their southern flare and style. This place is perfect for a quick meal, or to take home for the whole family.
Conclusion
Middletown, NJ, offers a culinary experience far beyond what one might expect from a suburban coastal town. From the comforting familiarity of casual dining to the refined elegance of upscale restaurants and the exciting exploration of international flavors, Middletown truly offers something for every palate. So, the next time you’re planning a visit to this charming corner of Monmouth County, remember to venture beyond the beach and discover the vibrant food scene that awaits. Whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite spot or a visitor eager to explore the region’s culinary delights, Middletown promises a delicious adventure. Don’t just take our word for it; start your culinary tour of Middletown today and discover your own hidden gems! What are your favorite restaurants in Middletown? Share your recommendations in the comments below! We are always looking for new favorites!
